Potty chair, built-in seat, or folding travel seat?

A floor potty chair, a lid with a toddler ring, and a folding seat for travel solve different bathroom problems. We bought all three.

By · Updated

See picks & pricesCompare the picks

Quick answer

For our home, the Mayfair was the keeper. We still use its built-in child ring every day. The green folding Silionce worked when we took it to Whidbey Island. The freestanding BabyBjörn chair never became a potty for our kids. If I were choosing again, I’d start with the home toilet and add a travel seat only if I needed one.

White potty chair, built-in child toilet seat and green folding travel seat arranged in a bathroom

Our recommendations

Mayfair NextStep2 child ring sitting flat on a white elongated toilet seat, with the lid raised

Our family’s pick

Mayfair NextStep2 elongated built-in potty seat

The child ring flips into the lid instead of sitting loose beside the toilet. Adults can use the same seat. Check your bowl shape; we bought the elongated version.

Check price

Worth knowing

Green frog-shaped folding potty ring opened over a white toilet seat with a gray carry pouch nearby

Also tested by our family

Silionce green folding travel potty seat

This folds into a travel bag and rests on an adult toilet. I would check its grip on each unfamiliar seat, then wipe it before packing it again.

Check price

Worth knowing

White BabyBjörn potty chair with gray base on a sunlit bathroom floor

Chair format we bought but did not use

BabyBjörn Potty Chair, White/Gray

This low chair lets a child keep their feet on the floor. Its inner bowl lifts out for cleaning. It takes a permanent spot in the bathroom, unlike the other two.

Check price

Worth knowing

The shortlist

Comparison of 3 picks: what each is best for and when to skip it
PickBest forSkip it if
Our family’s pickMayfair NextStep2 elongated built-in potty seatPersonally testedA shared home toiletRound bowl or travel
Also tested by our familySilionce green folding travel potty seatPersonally testedTrips and unfamiliar toiletsPermanent home setup
Chair format we bought but did not useBabyBjörn Potty Chair, White/GrayFeet on the floorPrefers the family toilet

Common questions

Did your kids use the BabyBjörn chair?

No. They covered it with stickers and left it at that. I never had to empty its bowl after a potty trip.

Does the built-in seat work on a round toilet?

Our exact Mayfair NextStep2 purchase is the elongated version. Check your bowl shape before ordering; do not buy an elongated seat for a round bowl.

Is the folding seat a portable toilet?

No. Our green Silionce folds into a bag and rests on an adult toilet. You still need a toilet, a stable fit and a way to clean the seat after use.

Should a child's feet dangle on the adult toilet?

AAP recommends a stool to support a child’s feet on a regular toilet. Pick one that sits securely and stay close while a young child uses it.

Before you buy

  • Where it lives: A chair stays on the bathroom floor. A built-in ring replaces the adult seat, while a folding ring can go in a bag.
  • What gets cleaned: With a chair, someone has to empty the bowl. The built-in and folding rings sit over a regular toilet, but both still need to be wiped down.
  • A child's feet and toilet fit: A low chair can let feet reach the floor. A regular toilet may need a stable footstool. Check the bowl shape before buying a built-in seat; our Mayfair is elongated.
  • Any product: check current recall information before buying — the kids' product recall tracker lists recent CPSC recalls of children's products.

How I narrowed it down

I checked the bowl and hinge features against the makers’ instructions. I did not time cleaning or test the folding ring on every toilet. The Mayfair card uses a maker photo. The other images are generated and do not show our bathroom.

  • Matched the three exact household purchases to current selected Amazon variants; all showed in-stock offers on October 31.
  • Checked BabyBjörn's removable-bowl care, Mayfair's elongated 1888SLOW specifications, and the exact Silionce folding-seat listing.
  • Checked AAP guidance on feet reaching the floor, foot support on an adult toilet and handwashing.

Matt is a Seattle dad of two boys, six and three. He's an engineer by habit and would rather read the spec sheet twice than send something back. Most guides here are research: product listings, safety guidance, recall records and what owners keep complaining about. The few things his family has actually used are marked personally tested, and nothing else is dressed up to look that way. He also keeps a weekly list of federal recalls on children's products. Read the review standards.

Sources
  1. BabyBjörn — Potty Chair and care FAQAccessed October 31, 2026
  2. Mayfair by Bemis — NextStep2 1888SLOWAccessed October 31, 2026
  3. Amazon — exact green Silionce folding seatAccessed October 31, 2026
  4. American Academy of Pediatrics — The Right Age to Potty TrainAccessed October 31, 2026